“Momma Doesn’t Want to Settle”: The Value of Mandatory Mediation — Part One


By Donald L. Swanson

An assistant pokes her head into my office and says, “Momma doesn’t want to settle.”  This assessment comes from observations made while escorting a husband/wife creditor to a conference room for today’s mediation session.  It’s a court-mandated mediation.  At issue are plan confirmation disputes in a Chapter 11 case. 

Sure enough, Momma does not want to settle.  And the mediation session concludes later that day without a settlement agreement.

It would be easy to cite this anecdote for the general proposition that mandatory mediations don’t work and shouldn’t be ordered.  But such a proposition would be wrong on at least two levels.

First, there is a type of mandatory mediation that does work—and works very well.  It’s planned-for mediation.  This type of mediation is mandated in advance by court rules of procedure: the rules specify that a mediation session shall occur before a case can go to trial.  Attorneys who practice under such rules know in advance that a mediation session must occur in a timely manner.  So, they plan for the mediation session and develop case strategies around the mediation requirement.  My experience is that mediation is highly-successful in courts with mandatory mediation rules.

Action Item:  So, here’s a suggestion for a simple procedural step: incorporate a mediation requirement into the court’s standard pre-trial order form for adversary proceedings.  Such provision could be as short and simple as requiring attorneys to, “Identify a date by which the parties will schedule a mediation session.”

Part II will address ad hoc orders mandating mediation.

Follow Don on Twitter here.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: