A plan of action (photo by Marilyn Swanson) By: Donald L Swanson There are lots of well-run businesses. But even the best of them face risks, from time to time, that threaten their existence. Such risks often arise from events that can’t be foreseen, let alone controlled. When such risks become reality for a business, what... Continue Reading →
Family Businesses in Financial Stress: Acts of Desperation and Bankruptcy
By Donald L. Swanson Desperate people do desperate things. And desperation leads even good people astray. So it is in the world of financial stress. Desperate people do desperate things: like providing sloppy financial statements to creditors, failing to assure that all collateral proceeds go to the proper place, and fudging on the truth here-and-there. All... Continue Reading →
Trade-Off Theory: For Minimizing Debtor Benefits In Subchapter V
Trade-Off: Bait & Tackle v. Coffee & Deli (Photo by Marilyn Swanson) By: Donald L Swanson There is trade-off theory going around for construing Subchapter V statutes. The theory is used to minimize benefits that Subchapter V statutes provide to debtors. The Theory The theory goes like this: elimination of the absolute priority rule is a... Continue Reading →
Shouldn’t Entrepreneurs Have After-Liquidation Bankruptcy Relief For The Risks They Take? (In re Hillman)
Entrepreneurship (Photo by Marilyn Swanson) By: Donald L Swanson Subchapter V eligibility requires a debtor to be “engaged in” commercial/business activities. Case Law Consensus Case law consensus is that such activities must exist on the petition filing date. That means a debtor cannot utilize Subchapter V when: business assets are fully-liquidated; unpaid debts are the only... Continue Reading →
Working Together: A Previously Successful Business’s General Counsel and Distressed-Debt Counsel
Working together? (photo by Grant Swanson) By: Donald L Swanson Answers to these two questions can get tricky: When should a previously successful business engage distress-debt counsel? What is the role of the business’s general counsel once that happens? Second Question: Role Here’s the answer to the second question first: The business’s general counsel needs to... Continue Reading →
An Example Of Subchapter V Accomplishing Its Purpose (In re Chip’s)
A special purpose: gas mask for a WWI horse By: Donald L Swanson It’s great to see a bankruptcy process that works—i.e., where both the debtor and its creditors are on board with a course of bankruptcy action. An excellent and recent example of such a thing involves a PPP loan, in which Debtor: dismisses its... Continue Reading →
Historical Prejudices Against Formerly-Successful Entrepreneurs Remain (In re Offer Space)
A link to the past (photo by Marilyn Swanson) By: Donald L Swanson Formerly-successful entrepreneurs have always been treated harshly in these United States. That may be hard to believe, given our market and credit economy and the importance of small businesses to it. But it’s true. And prejudices against formerly-successful entrepreneurs remain in today’s bankruptcy statutes.... Continue Reading →
Subchapter V: Early Termination Of A Trustee’s Services Under A Consensual Plan (§ 1183(c))
An early end By Donald L. Swanson A Subchapter V trustee has various duties established by statute (see 11 U.S.C. § 1183(b)). Such duties are substantial and important, but most are concluded upon confirmation of a Subchapter V plan. Administrative Expense—Early Termination Savings Of necessity, a Subchapter V trustee’s performance of statutory duties creates an... Continue Reading →
Lack of Experience — And Filing A Subchapter V Case
Utilizing and gaining experience from another (photo by Marilyn Swanson) By: Donald L Swanson It’s been a while—quite a long while, actually—since bankruptcy cases were booming. A Problem The result of such time lag is this: younger attorneys have missed-out on opportunities to grow in the bankruptcy realm; andthe bankruptcy bar is aging, without adequate development... Continue Reading →
Subchapter V Eligibility: Engaged In “Activities,” Not “Operations” (In re Offer Space)
Activity (Photo by Marilyn Swanson) By: Donald L Swanson A recent Bankruptcy Court opinion, In re Offer Space, LLC, [fn. 1] adds an important statutory distinction to the “engaged in” criterion analysis for Subchapter V eligibility, under § 1182(1)(A). The distinction is this (emphasis added): § 1182(1)(A) refers to a person “engaged in commercial or... Continue Reading →