On Bankruptcy and Mediation
By Donald L. Swanson Here's a proposal: Mediation among disputing parties should be a condition precedent for a final confirmation hearing on a contested Chapter 11 plan. The short history of bankruptcy mediation bears out the value of this proposal. --Songs of praise have been sung everywhere (in a bankruptcy / professional sort of way)... Continue Reading →
By Donald L. Swanson Eons ago, as measured by the short history of bankruptcy mediation, we are representing a creditor in a contentious Chapter 11 case. The case has many creditors, a wide range of constituencies and a chaotic existence. Efforts to bring order are having limited success. So someone suggests mediation. Most parties think... Continue Reading →
Action Item. An urgency and an immediacy exist in business bankruptcy cases to preserve and maximize value—otherwise there will be nothing for creditors to fight over. Mediation plans, strategies and models must provide immediate help in these urgent situations.
By Donald L. Swanson Non-bankruptcy cases usually have a different priority than bankruptcy cases: namely painting a picture v. maximizing value. In non-bankruptcy cases, an event or series of events occur, and the focus is, typically, on (i) painting a clear picture of what happened, and (ii) assigning or absolving liability accordingly. In non-bankruptcy cases,... Continue Reading →
Action Item. Preparation efforts must be made in a multi-party mediation before the parties will be ready for final mediation sessions.
By Donald L. Swanson Two-party and three-party mediations can fit well into a one-and-done session model. But four and more parties are difficult to manage in a one-and-done. Consider this: in a four-party mediation that begins at 9:30 a.m. with a 30 minute joint meeting and a 30 minute caucus with each party, it’ll be... Continue Reading →
By Donald L. Swanson I’m in a mediation session for a state court commercial case. The parties have been at it for a couple years. And everyone’s expectation is that this will be a one-and-done session. One of the first things Plaintiff’s president says to me is, “Can you believe we’ve paid over [$xxx] in... Continue Reading →
Action Item. All participants in a bankruptcy mediation need to understand, in advance, that a discovery vacuum, (1) might require a recess in the mediation session until the discovery vacuum can be filled, or (2) needs to be identified and addressed in pre-session communications..
By Donald L. Swanson I’m mediating a bankruptcy valuation dispute between a bank secured creditor and debtor. The asset is a building in need of repair. The dispute has been pending for a short while, and a hearing on declaration evidence is to occur soon. During the mediation, the banker says: “We need to see... Continue Reading →
Action Item. At every significant development in a bankruptcy case, beginning at its earliest stages, parties should consider whether a mediation process might be helpful immediately in resolving remaining disputes. #bankruptcy #mediation #bankruptcymediation
MEDIATBANKRY 